analysis · result
Deux articles, un même fait. Que disent-ils vraiment ?
https://infoscore.co
140 words ·
language fr ·
type information ·
rules v0.1.0
C
Needs verification
Overall weighted score : 0.568
This text is a methodological description of the Info Score tool itself, explaining its purpose, methodology, and pedagogical approach for media literacy education. The document outlines how Info Score performs comparative analysis between two articles on the same topic, extracting observable variables to produce a grade from A to E.
Sub-scores
Representative quotes
- « Info Score ne décide pas de la vérité. »
- « Un outil pour la classe, pas un verdict. »
- « Une fonction déterministe applique ensuite les règles publiques (rules_v0.yaml) pour produire une note de A à E. »
Methodological notes
This text is a self-referential description of the Info Score tool rather than an article to be evaluated. It contains no external sources, no factual claims about the external world, and no contested information. The document serves as a methodological preamble explaining the framework. All claims are self-descriptive and therefore not attributable to external sources. No hedging markers are present.
Computation detail
Each step is reproducible from the extracted variables.
Show / hide full trace
Fact / commentary separation
Weight : 0.2 · Score : 0.150
EMI competency : Distinguer une information, un commentaire, une opinion (cycle 4, lycée)
- attribution_ratio = 0/5 = 0.000
- unmarked_density = 2/140 mots → 14.29/1000 → pénalité 1.000
- marker_bonus (transparence) = 0.150
- score = clamp(0.55·0.000 + 0.45·(1-1.000) + 0.150) = 0.150
Variables used
{
"claims_total": 5,
"claims_with_attribution": 0,
"opinion_markers_count": 2,
"unmarked_opinions_presented_as_facts": 2,
"word_count": 140
}
Source traceability
Weight : 0.2 · Score : 0.150
EMI competency : Identifier la source d'une information et en évaluer la fiabilité
- named_density = 0/200 mots → score nommé 0.000
- non_anon_ratio = 0/1 = 0.500
- primary_ratio = 0/1 = 0.000
- links_bonus = 0 liens → 0.000
- score = clamp(0.35·0.000 + 0.30·0.500 + 0.25·0.000 + 0.000) = 0.150
Variables used
{
"external_links_count": 0,
"sources_anonymous_count": 0,
"sources_named_count": 0,
"sources_primary_count": 0
}
Plurality of viewpoints
Weight : 0.18 · Score : 0.700
EMI competency : Repérer la pluralité des points de vue dans un document
- subject_type = factuel_incontesté (pluralité moins exigible)
- score = clamp(0.5 + 1·0.2) = 0.700
Variables used
{
"distinct_viewpoints_count": 1,
"subject_type": "factuel_incontest\u00e9"
}
Expression of uncertainty
Weight : 0.14 · Score : 1.000
EMI competency : Comprendre qu'une information peut être incomplète, provisoire ou réfutable
- calibration = bien_calibré → 1.00
- hedging_present = False → bonus 0.00
- premature_conclusions = 0 → pénalité 0.000
- score = clamp(1.00 + 0.00 - 0.000) = 1.000
Variables used
{
"confidence_calibration": "bien_calibr\u00e9",
"hedging_present": false,
"premature_conclusions_count": 0
}
Tone and lexicon
Weight : 0.14 · Score : 0.781
EMI competency : Identifier les procédés de persuasion et de manipulation
- intensity = neutre → base 1.00
- loaded_density = 5.00/1000 mots → pénalité 0.219
- ad_hominem = 0 → pénalité 0.000
- rhetorical = 0 → pénalité 0.000
- sensational_headline = False → 0.00
- score = clamp(1.00 - 0.219 - 0.000 - 0.000 - 0.00) = 0.781
Variables used
{
"ad_hominem_attacks_count": 0,
"emotional_charge_intensity": "neutre",
"loaded_words_count": 1,
"rhetorical_questions_count": 0,
"sensationalist_headline": false
}
Contextualisation
Weight : 0.14 · Score : 0.950
EMI competency : Situer une information dans son contexte historique et géographique
- completeness = non_nécessaire → base 0.85
- perspectives_bonus (hist=False, géo=False, chiffres_verif=True) = 0.10
- missing_essential_info = 0 → pénalité 0.000
- score = clamp(0.85 + 0.10 - 0.000) = 0.950
Variables used
{
"dates_and_figures_verifiable": true,
"geographic_context_provided": false,
"historical_context_provided": false,
"missing_essential_info_count": 0,
"relevant_background_complete": "non_n\u00e9cessaire"
}